Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter
Justice & The Courts

Bell County Zeroed Its Next Treasurer’s Salary Under a 1987 Law. Now the Law Is in Federal Court

Bell County Zeroed Its Next Treasurer’s Salary Under a 1987 Law. Now the Law Is in Federal Court

Bell County’s incoming treasurer sued the county in federal court Nov. 19, asking a judge to strike down a Texas law that requires county officials who campaigned to abolish their office to file an affidavit declining their salary.

Adriane Hodges, who takes office Jan. 1, ran on a promise to work toward eliminating the treasurer’s office and folding its duties into the county auditor’s. After she won, the Bell County Commissioners Court set the treasurer’s salary at $0 beginning Jan. 1, citing Local Government Code §152.052. The suit, filed in the Western District of Texas with the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, argues the statute punishes one side of a political debate and compels her to sign a statement she says is false. It asks for a preliminary injunction before her affidavit deadline, Jan. 6.

The case puts a statute on trial that has sat in the code since 1987 and, by Hodges’s account, has never been enforced against an unwilling official. It also lands six weeks before a Legislature that could repeal it.

Newsletter

Latest News, Direct To Your Inbox

Get the most important Texas news and conversations delivered to your inbox.

Section 152.052 applies to a county or precinct officer who, during the campaign, “publicly advocated the abolition of the office.” Such an officer “shall file an affidavit” with the county payroll officer within five days of taking office “stating that the officer elects not to be paid,” including how and by when the officer intends to seek abolition. Once the affidavit is filed, the payroll officer must stop any paycheck not yet cashed.

The statute does not say a commissioners court may set the salary to zero itself. It puts the act on the officer. Bell County’s budget, adopted in August over Hodges’s objection, did it for her, effective the day she takes office. [Ask the county judge and county attorney what authority the court relied on for the $0 line, and whether the county’s position is that the affidavit is mandatory.]

Abolishing the office is not the county’s call either. County treasurer is a constitutional office, and ending it in a given county takes a constitutional amendment passed by the Legislature and approved by voters statewide. Ten counties have done it, most recently Galveston, whose treasurer Hank Dugie campaigned on abolition, declined his salary voluntarily and saw the office end in 2024. Hodges has cited that precedent, and another: Martha Whitehead, who campaigned for state treasurer in 1994 on abolishing the office and drew her salary until voters ended it.

The salary was not the court’s only response. In September, commissioners adopted an investment policy naming the outgoing treasurer, Gaylon Evans, and a first assistant auditor as the county’s investment officers, and created an investment committee, moving investment authority away from the office Hodges will hold. Hodges defeated Evans in the March Republican primary, 52.5 percent to 47.5 percent, and ran unopposed in November.

Hodges filed a grievance with the county in August and told the Killeen Daily Herald then that she considered the salary proposal retaliatory. “The last thing I hope for is litigation at taxpayers’ expense,” she said at the time. In FIRE’s announcement of the suit, she put it this way: “That’s what I told the voters, and that’s what they elected me to do. Rather than accept that, the county punished me for my speech.”

[County response placeholder: Judge David Blackburn, county attorney, or the court’s August budget discussion on video.]

The complaint says the statute discriminates by viewpoint, because a candidate who promises to keep or expand the office faces no penalty, and compels speech, because the affidavit requires the officer to say she “elects” not to be paid. “If Adriane had lied or hidden her plans to eliminate the treasurer’s office, she would be able to draw a public salary while implementing that policy,” FIRE staff attorney Heather Pincus said in the release.

The question has been asked of the state before. In 2022 the Galveston County auditor asked the attorney general whether §152.052 “creates content-based discrimination on campaign speech” and what compelling interest it served. The request is listed as closed; no opinion appears under it. [

A second suit is running alongside this one. FIRE sued the Texas Ethics Commission earlier this month over the commission’s reading of campaign-finance law, under which free legal representation for Hodges could count as a political contribution and a third-degree felony for both the group and the officeholder. FIRE asked the court to block that interpretation so the Bell County case could proceed.

The statute has been revisited once. A 2007 bill would have let candidates file an irrevocable affidavit declining pay before the election rather than after; the House analysis recorded no opposition but the bill did not become law. No bill touching §152.052 appears among measures prefiled so far for the 90th Legislature, which convenes Jan. 12.


Newsletter

Latest News, Direct To Your Inbox

Get the most important Texas news and conversations delivered to your inbox.