Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter
Economy

Comptroller’s Own Estimate Puts Cost of Three Sales-Tax Rule Changes at $2.4 Billion in First Year

Comptroller’s Own Estimate Puts Cost of Three Sales-Tax Rule Changes at $2.4 Billion in First Year

Three sales-tax rule changes proposed by Texas Comptroller Don Huffines would cost the state’s general revenue fund about $2.42 billion in fiscal year 2027 and about $4.9 billion a year by 2032, according to the agency’s own fiscal notes, published in the Nov. 20 Texas Register. Cities, counties and transit authorities would lose another $644 million in the first year.

The three proposals would stop taxing cloud computing, web hosting and artificial-intelligence services as “data processing”; stop taxing video streaming; and restore a sales-tax exemption for compressors used in oil and gas operations. The comptroller’s office announced the cloud and streaming changes in press releases this week, which The Dispatch reported Nov. 19 and Nov. 18. Neither release carried the cost figures. The Register filing does.

The numbers matter because lawmakers write the 2028-29 state budget when the 90th Legislature convenes in January. Taken together, the agency’s estimates for fiscal 2028 and 2029 come to about $5.96 billion in lost general revenue over that two-year budget, by The Dispatch’s addition of the three fiscal notes.

Newsletter

Latest News, Direct To Your Inbox

Get the most important Texas news and conversations delivered to your inbox.

The largest change is to the rule on data processing. The Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, the agency that collects state sales tax, proposes to define a taxable data processing service narrowly: one where the provider processes data the customer supplies and returns it in an organized, usable form. Storing or manipulating data alone would not count. Neither would a customer’s own use of a provider’s software or computing power. The proposal names cloud computing, artificial intelligence and quantum computing as “hosted technology services” that are not taxable data processing.

Tetyana Melnyk, the comptroller’s chief revenue estimator, put the state cost of that change alone at $1.95 billion in fiscal 2027, rising each year to $4.29 billion in fiscal 2032. Local governments would lose $507 million in the first year and $1.12 billion in 2032. A related change, taxing software sales only to the extent the software is used in Texas, would reduce revenue further by an amount the agency said “cannot be estimated.”

The streaming proposal would treat video delivered over the internet as something other than cable television service, and not as a taxable amusement. Its fiscal note estimates a $290 million state loss in fiscal 2027, growing to $376 million in 2032, plus $84 million in local losses the first year.

The compressor proposal would return to a 1999 agency ruling that treated compressors used in oil and gas operations as exempt manufacturing equipment. It would end a staff practice of taxing part of their use as transportation. The state cost is estimated at $183 million in fiscal 2027 and $240 million in 2032, with $53 million in first-year local losses.

The agency’s case for the changes is in the same filings. Melnyk wrote that the cloud and software proposal would benefit the public “by reducing costs and uncertainty for businesses” over how computer hardware, programs and related services are taxed, and that it would have an “insignificant effect on this state’s economy.” The filings do not say how the lost revenue would be replaced.

For local governments, the losses come out of sales tax that many use to hold down property-tax rates. The comptroller’s office announced $1.4 billion in local sales tax allocations this month, The Dispatch reported Nov. 16. The fiscal notes do not break the local losses down by city or county.

The changes are proposals, not final rules. The comptroller must receive public comments within 30 days of publication, which falls Dec. 20, 2026. The agency can adopt the rules after that.

Lawmakers will see the effect first in the comptroller’s Biennial Revenue Estimate, the forecast of available money that sets the ceiling on the budget they can pass.

Key facts

  • The Texas comptroller published three proposed sales-tax rule changes (34 TAC §§3.300, 3.308, 3.313) in the Texas Register on Nov. 20, 2026.
  • Combined estimated loss to state general revenue: about $2.42 billion in fiscal 2027 and about $4.90 billion in fiscal 2032, per the agency’s fiscal notes.
  • Combined estimated local loss to cities, counties and transit authorities: about $644 million in fiscal 2027.
  • The cloud computing, hosting and AI change accounts for $1.95 billion of the fiscal 2027 state loss.
  • Public comments are due 30 days after publication (Dec. 20, 2026).

Newsletter

Latest News, Direct To Your Inbox

Get the most important Texas news and conversations delivered to your inbox.