House Bill 1234 (90th Legislature), filed Nov. 18 by Rep. Cassandra Garcia Hernandez, would limit how much money a home, renter’s or condominium insurer can hold back from the first payment on a replacement-cost claim to 20% of the insurer’s estimated repair cost, minus the deductible. The bill is a refile of a 2025 measure that passed the Texas House 88-33 and then died in the Senate without a committee hearing.
The bill targets a common gap in property claims. Many Texas homeowners buy replacement-cost coverage, which promises to pay what it costs to repair or replace damaged property. But insurers often pay the depreciated value first and release the rest, known as the holdback, only after the work is finished. That leaves the homeowner to cover part of the repair up front. HB 1234 would not eliminate the holdback, but it would set a ceiling on it.
Under the introduced text, a policy with replacement-cost coverage “must provide that in a valid claim for loss of or damage to insured property, the insurer must not reduce an initial payment by an amount greater than 20 percent” of its estimated repair or replacement cost, minus the deductible. Once the homeowner documents that repairs are complete and has paid the deductible, the insurer must pay the remainder. The insurer would still never owe more than the cost to replace the property “with property of a like kind and quality.”
The rule would apply to every company writing residential property insurance in Texas, including county mutuals, Lloyd’s plans and reciprocal exchanges. It would cover policies issued or renewed on or after Jan. 1, 2028. The bill would take effect Sept. 1, 2027.
In 2025 the author told the House Insurance Committee that the up-front gap delays repairs, can let homes deteriorate further, and “inadvertently punishes lower-income homeowners who cannot afford the upfront cost,” according to the committee’s bill analysis of the earlier version, House Bill 854 (89th Legislature).
That bill’s record shows where the fight lines are. The Insurance Committee approved a substitute 6-2 on May 2, 2025. The full House passed it May 13, 2025, on an 88-33 record vote, according to the House Journal. The Senate received it May 14 and took no further action. The Legislative Budget Board’s fiscal note projected no significant cost to the state.
At the committee’s April 30, 2025 hearing, the witness list shows support from the Texas Association of Public Insurance Adjusters, which represents adjusters hired by policyholders; Texas Watch, a consumer advocacy group; AARP Texas; the Texas Trial Lawyers Association; and Texas Realtors. Opposition came from industry groups: the Insurance Council of Texas, the American Property Casualty Insurance Association, the National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies, Chubb and the Texas Coalition for Affordable Insurance Solutions. The Texas Department of Insurance registered as a neutral resource witness. The records list the groups’ positions; they do not summarize their arguments.
HB 1234 is the third prefiled bill this cycle aimed at depreciation holdbacks. House Bill 1116 by Rep. Morgan, covered by the Dispatch on Nov. 17, would give homeowners two years after a claim payment to recover withheld depreciation. House Bill 1182 by Rep. Barry, filed Nov. 16, would require insurers to disclose their depreciation schedules in quotes and policy forms. HB 1234 is the only one of the three to have passed a chamber before. Both HB 1116 and HB 1182 would add a section numbered 2301.011 to the Insurance Code, a drafting conflict that would have to be resolved if both advance.
The bill reaches the Legislature at a time of rising concern over homeowners insurance costs, a subject the Dispatch has followed in coverage of the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association’s finances and of health and insurance cost bills filed this fall.
No Senate companion had been identified as of Nov. 18. HB 1234 awaits referral to a House committee after the 90th Legislature convenes Jan. 12, 2027.
Key facts
- HB 1234 (Garcia Hernandez) was filed Nov. 18, 2026 (Texas Legislature Online).
- It caps an insurer’s holdback on a replacement-cost home, renter’s or condo claim at 20% of estimated repair cost minus the deductible (bill text, new Ins. Code Sec. 2002.007).
- It applies to policies issued or renewed on or after Jan. 1, 2028; effective Sept. 1, 2027 (bill text).
- The 2025 version, HB 854, passed the House 88-33 on May 13, 2025, and died in the Senate (TLO history; House Journal).
- The LBB projected no significant state fiscal impact for the 2025 version (fiscal note, May 5, 2025).