Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter
Agencies

Two Filed Bills Would Make State Takeovers of Texas School Districts Harder to Start or Quicker to End

Two Filed Bills Would Make State Takeovers of Texas School Districts Harder to Start or Quicker to End

Two lawmakers filed bills Nov. 9 that would rewrite the law the Texas Education Agency (TEA) used to take over Houston ISD. Sen. Molly Cook of Houston would raise the bar for a takeover and require the state to step back once a district’s struggling schools recover. Rep. Nicole Collier of Fort Worth would go further and return a district to its elected trustees if state managers fail to fix the problem within two years.

The stakes are concrete for families in districts under state control or close to it. Under current law, a single campus rated unacceptable for five straight years requires the education commissioner to act. That rule led to the 2023 replacement of Houston ISD’s elected board with a state-appointed board of managers. The same law will apply when TEA releases final 2026 school ratings Dec. 11.

Senate Bill 241, by Cook with Sens. Carol Alvarado, Roland Gutierrez and Taylor Rehmet, amends the section of the Education Code on continued low ratings. Now, a takeover or campus closure is triggered when “a campus” is rated unacceptable five years in a row, and the commissioner “shall” order one. The bill changes the trigger to 10% of a district’s campuses and changes “shall” to “may.” In a district with 270 campuses, roughly Houston ISD’s size, that would mean 27 chronically low-rated schools instead of one.

Newsletter

Latest News, Direct To Your Inbox

Get the most important Texas news and conversations delivered to your inbox.

SB 241 also changes how a takeover ends. The law now says the commissioner “may” remove a board of managers only if each campus behind the appointment earns an acceptable rating for two consecutive years. Under the bill, the commissioner “shall” remove the board once that happens.

House Bill 210, by Collier, sets an automatic exit triggered by failure rather than success. If the commissioner installs a conservator, a board of managers or other outside management because of academic performance, the bill says the elected trustees “shall resume management” if “the basis for the commissioner’s action continues to exist” after two consecutive years under state management. The two years include the year of the appointment. Once trustees are back, the commissioner could not order another academic takeover until after the fifth consecutive school year under the elected board.

HB 210 would also require automatic-termination terms in management contracts for campuses run by outside operators. Its changes would apply starting with the 2027-28 school year.

The bills land in a running argument over whether takeovers work. Houston ISD Superintendent Mike Miles, appointed by Education Commissioner Mike Morath, has told senators the district’s turnaround is the largest in the state, as the Dispatch reported. Rachel White, a researcher who studies school governance, has said the evidence that takeovers improve student outcomes is thin, in an interview with the Dispatch.

The trade-off is plain in the text. The current single-campus trigger forces state action for students in a school that has been rated unacceptable for five years. Under SB 241, a large district could keep several schools at failing ratings for years without facing state management. The bills would instead put control back with elected boards that answer to voters, and HB 210 would end a takeover that has not fixed the problem in two years.

Both bills would take effect immediately with a two-thirds vote in each chamber, or otherwise Sept. 1, 2027. They await committee referral after the 90th Legislature convenes in January. Before then, the Dec. 11 ratings will show which districts face action under the law as it stands.

Key facts

  • SB 241 (Cook, Alvarado, Gutierrez, Rehmet) and HB 210 (Collier) were filed Nov. 9, 2026 (Texas Legislature Online).
  • Current Education Code §39A.111: one campus rated unacceptable five consecutive years requires the commissioner to appoint a board of managers or close the campus.
  • SB 241: trigger becomes 10% of a district’s campuses, and the order becomes discretionary; board of managers must be removed after two consecutive acceptable years.
  • HB 210: trustees resume control if the problem persists after two years of state management; no new academic takeover until after five years.
  • TEA final 2026 accountability ratings are scheduled for Dec. 11.

Newsletter

Latest News, Direct To Your Inbox

Get the most important Texas news and conversations delivered to your inbox.