Rep. Matt Morgan of Katy filed three bills Nov. 12 that would change what Texas homeowners get from their property insurance after a storm. One would give policyholders two years to collect money an insurer holds back until repairs are done. A second would void arbitration clauses that require customers, but not insurers, to give up their day in court. The third would make coverage for detached garages, fences and sheds something a homeowner must choose rather than a standard part of the policy.
The bills arrive as the Legislature heads into a session where property insurance costs are on the agenda. Two of the bills would expand policyholders’ rights after a loss. The third would shrink the coverage a standard policy must include, in exchange for a choice the homeowner makes up front.
House Bill 1116 deals with depreciation. Many policies pay the depreciated value of a damaged roof or fixture first and withhold the rest until the owner finishes repairs. The bill says a property policy “must permit an insured to recover depreciation withheld from a claim for a covered loss until the second anniversary of the date the insurer issues a claim payment for the loss.” It also bars insurers from counting that money as part of their defense costs or deducting it from defense-coverage limits. Morgan filed the same proposal in 2025 as House Bill 4268. That bill was left pending in committee in April 2025, according to Texas Legislature Online.
House Bill 1117 would create a new chapter of the Insurance Code on binding arbitration. That is a process in which a private arbitrator, not a judge or jury, decides a dispute, usually with no appeal. The bill says an arbitration provision in a property and casualty policy “is void and unenforceable” if it requires the policyholder to arbitrate before going to court while keeping court remedies “exclusively for the insurer.” The same applies if it waives the policyholder’s remedies under state consumer-protection and prompt-payment laws, shortens the time to sue, requires a Texas resident to arbitrate out of state, or charges a fee “substantially greater” than a district court filing fee. An arbitration agreement could be enforced only if both sides sign it after the dispute arises and it gives both equal rights. The bill reaches county mutuals, Lloyd’s plans, agents, brokers and third-party administrators.
House Bill 1118 runs the other way on coverage. “Notwithstanding any other law,” it says, a residential or commercial property policy “is not required to provide other structures coverage.” Insurers could include that coverage only if the policyholder “affirmatively elects” it and it appears on the declarations page or an endorsement. A policy without it would have to say so on the declarations page. The bill does not say whether premiums would change.
All three bills would apply to policies delivered, issued or renewed on or after Jan. 1, 2028, and take effect Sept. 1, 2027.
The bills turn on a familiar trade-off. Holding back depreciation until repairs are done is meant to make sure claim money goes to the repair, and arbitration can settle disputes faster and more cheaply than a lawsuit. A longer collection window and fewer arbitration limits give homeowners more leverage, but they can also raise insurers’ claim and legal costs, which feed into rates. The Dispatch has covered competing bills on how Texas approves insurance rates and the windstorm insurer’s borrowing for Hurricane Beryl claims.
The bills await committee referral when the 90th Legislature convenes in January.
Key facts
- HB 1116, HB 1117 and HB 1118 by Rep. Matt Morgan (House District 26) were filed Nov. 12, 2026 (Texas Legislature Online).
- HB 1116: two years to recover withheld depreciation after the insurer’s claim payment; a refile of 2025’s HB 4268, left pending in committee.
- HB 1117: voids one-sided or remedy-limiting binding arbitration clauses in property and casualty policies; post-dispute, signed, equal-rights agreements only.
- HB 1118: “other structures” coverage becomes opt-in, with a declarations-page notice when it is excluded.
- All apply to policies on or after Jan. 1, 2028.